Difficult Dialogues

NOTE: To use the advanced features of this site you need javascript turned on.

Home

Difficult Dialogues is a forum to encourage a culture of dialogue about important subjects that South Africans have found it difficult to speak honestly or to draw and implement effective public policy responses.

LOW HANGING FRUIT: Seven steps Zuma could take now
Written by John Matisonn   
Sunday, 07 June 2009 15:26

Advice to the Zuma cabinet fits broadly into two categories. Both sets of advisers are half right, but most miss half the point.

The business community, afraid of a shift to the left, calls for the status quo. “This is a time for caution, for holding the ship steady through the storm and ensuring we survive in decent shape,” wrote one respected commentator, representing that view.

That advice is surely right as far as it goes. Macro-economic policy has been in good hands. Our banks are amongst the soundest in the world. There is a planned stimulus package of infrastructure spending which is now being rolled out.

We don’t want to throw away our hard-earned reputation for fiscal responsibility. And the state should be wary of moving into areas of the economy it does not understand and cannot service.

Read more... [LOW HANGING FRUIT: Seven steps Zuma could take now]
 
2009 Election brought Political Realignment
Written by John Matisonn   
Tuesday, 28 April 2009 00:00

Everyone else is doing it, so I’m going to have a bash too. Predict the new cabinet. You will know if I’m on track or a damn fool soon enough.

But first, an anecdote, perhaps apocryphal.

While Thabo Mbeki was still president, he sat next to a Stellenbosch-based tycoon, who said the following.

“In business, if one of my companies is in trouble, I take my best manager, put him in charge of it, and get him to fix it,” said the tycoon. “I don’t see this happening in government.

“You have, heading the South African Revenue Service, one of the best public servants in the world in Pravin Gordhan. Why don’t you swap him with Jackie Selebi, make him commissioner of police and Selebi head of SARS?

“The result would be fabulous. There’d be no crime in South Africa, and no one would pay tax!”

The former president’s response is not recorded.

Read more... [2009 Election brought Political Realignment]
 
It’s about Service Delivery, Stupid
Written by John Matisonn   
Thursday, 23 April 2009 00:00

“I was the decoy. While Helen Zille was calling me names, Jacob Zuma was sprinting to the Union Buildings.”

ANC Youth League president Julius Malema’s boast at Walter Sisulu University in East London just before voting day could be the epitaph for this election. The Democratic Alliance leader allowed herself to be distracted from her own strengths.

What was overlooked was that this election was about two questions: which party would be the champion of the constitution, and which party would be the champion of delivery.

Zille nailed the first, and got distracted from the second, despite a track record that put her in a strong position to claim she could deliver against an ANC taking the heat for widespread delivery failure.

From the beginning of the campaign the DA was in tune with most of the media, the other opposition parties, as well as important voices in the law, the church and academia in reflecting concern about a Jacob Zuma presidency.

Read more... [It’s about Service Delivery, Stupid]
 
Zimbabwe power has changed – can we?
Written by John Matisonn   
Monday, 30 March 2009 00:00

Power in Zimbabwe has reached a tipping point.

If you listen carefully to the sounds coming from Zimbabwe, the sound you are hearing is the shift of power from the sclerotic, corrupt old establishment to a new generation. And it requires clear, new policies from South Africa and governments around the world.

For years there have been increasingly anguished debates about how to deal with Robert Mugabe, between those who said “fight him till he’s beaten” and those who said work for change from within.

But now, for better or worse, there is a government whose power is growing by the minute. The workaholic Finance Minister Tendai Biti and Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai have promised to pay salaries in hard currency, and they have met their first payrolls. Goods are coming back into the shops.

This deal is South Africa’s deal. South Africa sacrificed its reputation as a human rights advocate for it. It sacrificed international respect. We sacrificed probably upwards of one percent of our growth rate for our plan for Zimbabwe. And that pain caused a disruptive flood of desperate refugees, bringing cholera and desperate hunger to South African streets.

Read more... [Zimbabwe power has changed – can we?]